Wednesday, February 9, 2011

The Myth of the Moderate District

Aaron Blake at the Washington Post talks about "The myth of the dying moderate." It's true that the moderate isn't dying but he's mistaken on this point:

What's more, when a moderate is kicked out of a swing district, he or she is often replaced by a moderate member of the other party -- or at least a member that learns quickly that he or she needs to be moderate if he or she wants to stay in office.


If you take a look at the membership of the Republican Main Street Partnership you'll see that the most common states for the congressmen are California, Illinois, Michigan, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. Aside from California and Pennsylvania none of these states have blue dog members. Of the 10 new RMSP members only two replaced Blue Dogs. RMSP members come from moderate to liberal districts in moderate to liberal states. Only 4 of the 45 congressmen come from a state John McCain won. A lot of them replaced party line Democrats, who while not the most liberal in the Democratic caucus they weren't moderates either.

The Blue Dogs come largely from conservative southern, plains, or mountain states. It's heavily Republican country, many in states won by John McCain. So they were replaced by conservative Republicans. There are moderate districts. These districts usually only have a Republican moderate if it's a blue state like New York or Illinois and a Democratic moderate in a red state like Georgia or Louisiana.

The states with both are California and Pennsylvania, which are very blue and light blue. So it's not surprising that Republican moderates represent districts in them. Blue Dogs in Pennsylvania tend to represent rural Republican area. In California, however, you have a number of Blue Dogs representing liberal districts. I don't have an explanation for this.

Edit: I checked National Journal's 2009 conservative/liberal scores. If you click on Blue Dogs and Main Street Partnership you'll discover that the most liberal Blue Dogs and the most conservative Main Streeters are in California. These are moderate groups, so their voting records indicate they shouldn't be members. So, yes there are Blue Dogs in California but they're most liberal in the coalition.

Monday, February 7, 2011

Early House Prediction

Based on what usually happens when a President runs for re-election a good prediction would be a Democratic gain of 15 House seats in 2012 to cut the Republican advantage to 227-208. How Obama does is unlikely to change that. The losses will likely be less due to Republican gerrymandering.

Here's what I'm thinking now:

Benefitting the Republican Party
North Carolina –Right now Democrats have a 7-6 advantage in congressional seats even though this is a Republican leaning state. They have control of redistricting for the first time and it’s conceivable the GOP could draw a map where with 10 districts having a Republican lean. A more conservative map would give them 9 seats with a decided advantage. I’m going to be a little conservative and predict an 8-5 Republican delegation.
Republicans +2, Democrats -2

Georgia – Republicans can draw a pretty favorable map here too. It’s possible for them to draw out both Sanford Bishop and John Barrow, but that might be too ambitious. Instead, Republicans can draw a new Republican district and get rid of one of those two.
Republicans +2, Democrats -1

Utah – Republicans have tried to draw Jim Matheson out of a district and I think they’ll succeed this time. It shouldn’t be hard to draw four safe Republican districts.
Republicans +2, Democrats -1

Iowa – Iowa will lose a seat and that doesn’t bode well for the Democrats. There are two strongly Republican districts and three weak Democratic ones. When you make these five districts into four, you could end up with four Republican leaning districts. I think the GOP will take either the 1st or 2nd from the Democrats and win the 3rd with Latham running against Boswell.
Republicans +1, Democrats -2

West Virginia – This state keeps getting worse for Democrats. Nick Rahall survived this year due to weak competition. The state will go heavily Republican in the Presidential race and that should be enough to doom Rahall.
Republicans +1, Democrats 0

New York – While Republicans and Democrats both will have a say in redistricting, I think it won’t bode well for the Democrats. The state loses two seats. Republicans only control two New York area seats, so the Democrats will be squeezed out of one. Upstate there’ll likely be several toss-up seats, with one pitting a Democrat against a Republican. I’m giving the GOP an edge there.
Republicans 0, Democrats -2

Massachusetts – Democrats have all ten seats and the state is losing one. The math only works one way.
Republicans 0, Democrats -1

Michigan – Republicans control redistricting and that should be enough for them to gerrymander a Democrat out of his seat.
Republicans 0, Democrats -1

Missouri – Popular speculation has Republicans and Black Democrats teaming up to save both Black Democrats and sacrifice Russ Carnahan.
Republicans 0, Democrats -1

Kentucky, Connecticut, Oregon, and Oklahoma all present opportunities for the GOP. Republicans will probably pick up at least one seat in these states.
Republicans +1, Democrats 0

Benefitting the Democratic Party
Florida – Republicans hold a 19-6 edge in the congressional delegation, a ridiculously enormous edge in a state where their share of the statewide vote would result in something like 14-11. The good news for the GOP is the state is adding two districts and the Republicans control redistricting. The bad news is that Fair Districts Florida won’t allow them to gerrymander the way they like. Right now there are three districts in Palm and Broward Counties that are D+1, D+13, and D+15. Without gerrymandering these will all be Democratic districts. Maybe I’m a little pessimistic for the GOP, but a 17-10 edge would still be pretty significant.
Republicans -2, Democrats +4

Illinois – Republicans hold an 11-8 edge in a state that is heavily Democratic. Democrats should be able to squeeze four downstate Republican districts into three and then make three of the seven Chicago area seats Democratic enough to take them.
Republicans -4, Democrats +3

Texas – Like Florida, Republicans hold a disproportionately high edge in congressional seats. Here it’s 23-9. To make those 23 seats safe, Republicans will have to pack Democrats into new districts and sacrifice three of the four new seats. If they end up with a 24-12 edge, they’ll have done well.
Republicans +1, Democrats +3

California – I have no idea how the redistricting commission will impact the delegation. I wouldn’t be surprised if the Democrats picked up five seats or the Republicans picked up three. There are strong arguments for both. I’ll choose something in between for now.
Republicans -2, Democrats +2

New Hampshire – Both districts are toss-ups, with the GOP controlling both right now. Odds are that they’ll lose one or the other.
Republicans -1, Democrats +1

Virginia – With Democrats still in charge of one House in the Virginia legislature the GOP will have a tough time creating districts where they’ll hold onto all their gains. It’s an 8-3 delegation now. A 7-4 edge will still be significant.
Republicans -1, Democrats +1

Arizona – The new seat could go either way, but I think there’ll be a new Hispanic majority district that will go Democratic.
Republicans 0, Democrats +1

Nevada – Republicans hold a 2-1 edge despite this state trending Democratic. If they can make Joe Heck safer, they’ll let the Democrats create a Democratic leaning district.
Republicans 0, Democrats +1

South Carolina – While it’s possible to create six Republican districts, I think the Justice Department will insist on them drawing a second majority minority district.
Republicans 0, Democrats +1

Washington – Population growth has been heavily in Democratic Seattle. A new district there will likely make the 3rd and 8th more Republican.
Republicans 0, Democrats +1

Ohio – Republicans control redistricting but currently have every district outside of Northern Ohio. There are too many marginal districts. Republicans may need to draw a Democratic district in Columbus, while only eliminating one Northern Ohio Democratic district. Being conservative will help Republicans retain the seats throughout the decade.
Republicans -2, Democrats 0

Louisiana – The state will lose a seat. Since it’ll retain the majority-minority district in New Orleans, it’ll be a GOP congressman who loses out.
Republicans -1, Democrats 0

New Jersey – Another one that could go either way. I have a feeling that the Democrats will come out on top.
Republicans -1, Democrats 0

Pennsylvania – Republicans control redistricting here too, but also have a high number of marginal seats. While they’ll likely squeeze the Democrats out of a seat in Western Pennsylvania, they might not be able to gerrymander that they won’t lose an Eastern Pennsylvania district.
Republicans -1, Democrats 0

113th congress: Republicans 237 Democrats 198 (Democrats +5)
I could see how Republicans could get as many as 262 seats or as few as 215, but I consider neither very likely.

Left Wing Media Bias

Conservatives often complain about left wing media bias and the left disputes this. Here is an interesting informative article, that appeared yesterday. It is accurate and some might not be able to detect bias. Subtle bias is bias.

1. The article implies that Republican congressmen only take the Koch advocated position because of money from the Koch brothers. If Republicans who haven’t taken money from the Koches largely had different positions, that’d be good journalism. I’m pretty sure that almost all Republicans hold this position regardless of contributions and have held it long before they got any contributions.

2. The article implies that the Democratic position is the best one for the American public and that the Republican position is only good for the oil and gas industry. The environment is a complicated issue that should be open to discussion whether regulations go too far and what the impact of the regulations will be. Stiffer regulations means business spends more money. They either raise prices or lay off people to compensate.


3. The article implies that the Koch brothers are responsible for the Democratic majority, Nancy Pelosi’s position. How many Republicans did they actually give significant money to and what was the percentage of the overall money spent on those races? How did the Democrats in those races spend? How does their spending compare to other outside spending, like unions, and spending by the Republican and Democratic parties? Republicans took the majority with 24 excess seats. I don’t think the Koches spent money in that many winning races.

4. The article implies that the Koches are behind the Cato Institute, the Federalist society, and the tea parties, without indicating what percentage of money spent comes from the Koches. The tea parties existed before the Koches got involved and their involvement is limited to Freedomworks providing assistance to tea parties. Tea parties don’t accept a heavy hand from anyone.


5. The article implies something sinister about the Koch conference without providing evidence or noting that there are thousands of such conferences put on by businesses every year.

6. The article waits until the last paragraph to note that the Democratic members of the committee are liberal environmentalists. Is this true? Did Henry Waxman replace those that weren’t? Environmental groups employee lobbyists, just like business groups do. They spend money, just like business groups do. Do business groups spend more money? No idea. Wouldn’t that be a nice thing to investigate?

Bias doesn’t just come from advocating a point of view. It comes from how you present the facts, what you support, and what you choose not to support. Journalism doesn’t have to be balanced, but it needs to be thorough and put in context. The Koches may be just as sinister as they make them out to be, but by leaving out important information all they’ve done is write an article which will fuel liberal paranoia and anger conservatives.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Did the Tea Party Hurt the Republicans in the Senate?

Conventional wisdom is that the tea party candidates cost the GOP at least 3 senate seats because they were weaker. There’s no way to know what would’ve happened in Colorado or Nevada, but Delaware would’ve likely flipped. Mike Castle was an unusual candidate. How would Christine O’Donnell have compared to anyone else?

I decided to compare the states that had similar 2008 Presidential spreads.


With Joe Miller we know that Lisa Murkowski was the better candidate since she beat him and the Democratic candidate. Mike Lee didn’t exceed John McCain’s 29 point 2008 margin, but exceeding that wouldn’t have been easy. John Boozman and David Vitter didn’t do any better. I doubt Bob Bennett would’ve been a better candidate. Of course they would’ve won this regardless.

Kentucky, Kansas, and West Virginia all had similar 2008 spreads. Jerry Moran won in a landslide, while Rand Paul won by a smaller margin and John Raese lost. There’s hardly enough data here to make a judgment, especially since Paul and Raese had serious challengers, and West Virginia is a far tougher state for a senate race than a Presidential one.

The last group doesn’t have a tea party candidate. They all won in lopsided races.

Marco Rubio is considered a tea party candidate, although his background as Florida Speaker of the House hardly makes him an outsider. He had a larger margin of victory than any other Republican in a similar state.


The next six states were somewhat more one sided for the Democrats in 2008. Charles Grassley was an incumbent, so he’s not a good comparison. Kelly Ayotte was an establishment candidate and her spread was next best. Ron Johnson and Pat Toomey, both considered tea party candidates, did very well. Ken Buck and Sharron Angle did a lot better than McCain, but were the worst of the group.

The last group were Obama landslide states. Tea Party favorite Christine O’Donnell exceeded McCain by 8 points, a total better than many of these candidates. Mark Kirk, an establishment moderate, fared best, while Dino Rossi did well too. Most of the rest couldn’t be considered establishment or tea party, although Carly Fiorina and Linda McMahon got the nod over a tea party candidate and a more establishment one.

It’s impossible to say definitively how the tea party candidates did, since the circumstances of individual races was a big factor. In most cases the establishment candidate raised more money and in some had a weak challenger. For the most part, however, the tea party candidates fared worse than the establishment candidates. So there’s likely some credence to the argument the tea party candidates hurt the GOP.

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Senate Coat Tails

Public opinion is that Obama helped Democratic performance. It's tough to argue with that. Obama had stronger showings than Kerry in most states and the Democrats won 20 of 35 Senate contests. How much help did Obama provide and more importantly, was it important for Obama to win a state to push the Democrat over the top?


Democrats did better in 21 of the 28 contests where both elections had a Republican and Democrat. Of course some elections had better Democratic candidates or better Republican candidates. Democratic recruitment was better in 2008 and Republican recruitment was worse, so we'd expect the chart to skew toward 2008. It's possible that the environment would've helped the Democrats, regardless of who ran for President. The overwhelming number of elections where the Democrats did better was so great that Obama's coat tails played some role, if not the entire role.

Let's look at Obama's percentage of the vote compared to the Democratic candidate to see if there's a correlation.


I'm no statistician, but the number of elections where Obama and the Senate candidate were close indicates some correlation. The races in red were open seats. In most of these the Democrat adhered closer to Obama's percentage. The races in yellow are those where the candidate lost the state but the party's candidate won. Here, the correlation isn't that high. It's likely that Obama helped the candidates, since the Democratic candidate won all of these states. There's something even curiouser, however. West Virginia and Louisiana were 2 of the 3 states where Obama did worse than Kerry. Obama wasn't a drag on either of these races. The Democratic incumbents won anyway. So Obama won't necessarily be a drag on Joe Manchin or Jon Tester in 2012.

Let's look at the last President's re-election campaign. Republican candidates heavily underperformed George W. Bush in 2004.


Bush may not have pulled his party's candidates to victory. Obama was a positive in most Senatorial races in 2008. That doesn't mean he will definitely be one in 2012.

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Senate News

In the last week or so we've had Kent Conrad's retirement, Joe Lieberman's retirement, Denny Rehberg entering the Montana senate race, and a poll showing Jon Bruning is ahead of Ben Nelson by 11 points.

I'm upping my prediction of Republican gains from 5.1 to 5.4 seats. That's not a lot but I already had these three seats as the most likely to flip. Since the GOP only needs 4 seats for the majority, there's probably about a 65-70% chance the chamber flips.

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Getting it

Charlie Cook, an elections expert, kind of gets it. He understands what I've been saying for the last two months. Democrats regaining the House is highly unlikely, although not impossible. The circumstances need to be right for a wave election and it's doubtful the climate will change into those circumstances. He mentions a government shut down, but that happened in 1995 and the Republicans only lose 8 seats in 1996. Wave elections occur almost always as a negative reaction to the sitting President or with an election of a new President. The Democrats can't benefit from either of these scenarios.

That's not to say the Democrats won't pick up seats. I'm pretty sure they will. I'd say they'd end up around 207 after the 2012 election if Obama is elected and 195 if he loses.